Thrifting Dupes for Online Finds

Sometimes I am bad and go surfing on the secondhand interwebs for things I wish I had in my closet. It never ends well (see here and here). Lately, I’ve had a bit of restraint, and have been rewarded with in-person dupes for my internet finds.

It started with this French Connection sweater, which was, alas, too small for me:

IMG_20171013_151327178

I loved that caramel-and-cream combo and the textured pattern, so I went looking online for that same sweater, with no luck. So instead of keeping an eye out online, I kept an eye out on my thrifting rounds for something similar:

IMG_6501

Cream & caramel colors? Check. Textured pattern? Check. This L.L. Bean sweater does the job, and for a lot less than the price of an online find.

Ta-da:

IMG_20171028_115315_355

 

In my French Connection searches online, I came across this fabulous tomato red number:

m_59108bea13302a7a4600660f
Source

I loved the color and the split/hi-lo hem. The price was right ($11 – although I still had to pay $6.49 for shipping). But there was no way to tell if it would fit. I put it out of my mind by thinking about how disappointing it would be to have it show up and be too small.

But then, lo and behold, for less than the selling price of the French Connection sweater online, my very first Eileen Fisher find hit the nail on the head:

IMG_6500

It’s 100% merino wool and a great fall color:

IMG_20171028_172920496

The lesson I’m supposed to learn from this is that when I’m tempted to snap up some online find, I’d do better to wait and let the thrift gods send me something just as good (or better!).

Buuuuuuut… after letting them sit for a few weeks, I just bought some cream-colored skinny jeans off the internet. I tried on a smaller size in the thrift store – that was my inspiration – so I am reasonably confident they’ll fit. Who knows, though – I’m 0 for 2 in terms of online thrift finds success. Let’s just hope this one breaks the streak!

 

What thrifting habit do you *know* you should give up, but you have a hard time leaving alone?

 

PS To all my American readers, Happy Thanksgiving! (And a VERY belated Thanksgiving to my Canadian readers as well.) May you thrift super-chic outfits with stretchy waistbands to accommodate all the delicious food you’ll eat this week!

Thrift Finds: October 2017

First up, I want to share with you all Nadia at Happy Malista’s recap from her 10×10 challenge; she shared her outfits as well as outfits from a few other bloggers whose challenges she enjoyed, including yours truly! It’s sometimes hard finding a style blogger whose style is close enough to your own to resonate but different enough to inspire you; Nadia’s 10×10 hits that sweet spot for me. She’s convinced me I need to replace the blazer I used to own that was kind of a spring take on moss green…

And now, on to my thrift finds from last month!  Starting with the NOs:

A great soft dark grey turtleneck with split hem, made of supima cotton, that was too baggy – sigh:

IMG_20171013_152719743

A Talbots sweater that made me feel like I live in a ski chalet – look at that great fringe!

IMG_20171013_153206604

A wonky fit in the torso, though:

IMG_20171013_153200362 (1)

I’m on the hunt for a caramel-colored turtleneck but this one was giant in the armpits:

IMG_20171013_152917179

It hid its ginormous pits well, though:

IMG_20171013_152912016

This dark cognac trench was a dream – 100% wool, and just had so much character:

IMG_20171013_160744484_BURST001

It was a little TOO oversized on me, and the color a bit intense – see how it’s the first thing your eye is drawn to in the picture, instead of my face? Sign of a tone mismatch.  Anyway, this would have fit my fantasy life (city dweller with a 20 minute walk across the Loop to get to my office) but not my real life (quick jog down the block to my office, then where do I stash this monster?), so I left it there.  Tear.

It’s hard to tell, but this riding jacket by Ralph Lauren was too big on me. The cut is very equestrian; can’t you see it paired with jodhpurs?

IMG_20171013_154652648

But here’s where it shines – velvet collar and some purple woven in with that moss green. It’s like heather in a blazer!

IMG_20171013_160343816

Various pants I tried out because I thought I needed grey jeans (probably not true):

IMG_20171013_154055468 IMG_20171013_153914420 IMG_20171013_153732837

Several sweaters that didn’t make the cut, such as:

Loft – loved the diamond pattern but it was scratchy-atchy-atchy, as one of my kid’s storybooks says:

IMG_20171013_152605229

Same with this Gap sweater – scratchy, and that neck plus those sleeves totally remind of the year 2000:

IMG_20171013_152216235

Too much blue in this green sweater by Land’s End – but it fit perfectly! (Their tops are usually too wide in the torso for me):

IMG_20171013_152111795

Italian wool from Banana Republic, too tight (that smudge is the mirror, not a sweater defect):

IMG_20171013_152418998

And a J. Crew dress that underwhelmed, I think mostly because it was short enough to need leggings, but lightweight enough to show any lumps and folds from underlayers:

IMG_20171026_163853216

That bottom half is navy, despite its greenish tinge in this photo.

 

And now, for the winners!

You’re familiar by now with my new cable knit sweater by Workshop by Andrea Jovine:

IMG_20171013_153359855

Here’s my new goose down coat by Larry Levine; it retails for up to $200 but thrifted for $20. I may not be psychologically ready for the cold, but I will be sartorially ready for it!

IMG_20171013_154535594

It’s just this side of dark charcoal, so hopefully it will not wash me out quite as much as pure black. Honestly, though, if I’m warm and I paid 10% of MSRP, I don’t care. Functional wins out over everything else in this case.

Here’s my first Eileen Fisher find! A bright, orangey red that is sort of intensely bright – what a great fall color:

IMG_20171026_164029416

Check out that split hem!

IMG_20171026_164024202

To wit, here it is styled:

IMG_20171031_090119432 IMG_20171028_172920496

And this tan/cream patterned sweater by L.L. Bean:

IMG_20171026_163718207
There’s a cat balancing on my phone!

…with a fun hi-lo split hem:

IMG_20171026_163725289

Here it is styled:

IMG_20171101_200831_843

And last but not least, this merino wool plaid scarf in colors that complement my wardrobe in stellar fashion:

IMG_20171016_173945_518IMG_20171024_165459875

 

Overall, a pretty good month.  Onward to November!

Did anything in my finds catch your eye?  What did you thrift this past month?